About hand counts
Ignorance, it seems, is just not bliss.
·
Saturday 23 December 2023
· 4 feedback
![](https://otb.cachefly.net/wp-content/uploads/2008/12/al-franken-ballots.jpg)
That Texas Tribune has a captivating (however not in a great way) story concerning the curiosity of many county-level Republican officers in Texas to hand-count the 2024 primaries: Texas Republicans in a rural county will hand-count ballots. Specialists say it is “a recipe for catastrophe.” Whereas, because the headline notes, it seems that just one county will accomplish that, the piece particulars how a variety of county-level GOP operations have been significantly contemplating the likelihood, together with in Dallas and Travis (i.e., Austin) counties.
When Gillespie County Republicans conduct their main election in March, they are going to rely votes in a reckless method: by hand, utilizing dozens of volunteers, with none machines.
Even when they will pull their costly, labor-intensive plan, they threat being sued, dropping candidates, or being reprimanded by the state. And so they can run up an enormous invoice with pointless prices.
“Hand counting is a recipe for catastrophe,” stated Bob Stein, a political science professor at Rice College and an election administration knowledgeable. He and most different consultants agree on this, and research again them up: The tactic is time-consuming, costly, much less correct and fewer safe than utilizing voting machines.
[…]
The occasion management in main counties has to date resisted a full hand rely. In Dallas County, administration determined that will be unattainable with present assets. In Travis County, the native GOP selected a considerably watered-down plan for hand counting, specializing in a small proportion of main ballots.
Anybody who has dealt a deck of taking part in playing cards after which counted to ensure there have been 52 is aware of that it’s insanely simple to make a mistake in a hand rely. And we’re speaking about excess of 52 poll papers.
Nevertheless, Gillespie County Republicans should now recruit and prepare a further 100 election employees to carry out the election day duties usually assigned to county election employees.
Then there may be the mammoth job of manually counting votes within the dozen or so races on the greater than 3,000 ballots anticipated to be solid within the main, racing towards the clock to complete earlier than the state’s 24-hour deadline for reporting outcomes.
However occasion official David Treibs, a district chairman who has spearheaded planning the hand rely, does not assume will probably be a lot bother.
“It is not likely difficult. If you happen to go ‘1, 2, 3, 4, 5,’ then you are able to do it,” Treibs, who has no expertise counting ballots by hand, informed Votebeat. “So it isn’t like calculus, you understand? When you have an excellent focus, I believe most individuals can do it.”
It is a nice illustration the place “frequent sense” utilized by non-experts results in very dangerous decisions.
Ben Adida, CEO of VotingWorks, a nonprofit voting programs vendor that helped the state of Georgia conduct a hand-count audit of the state’s 2020 presidential outcomes, agreed that hand counting didn’t equal calculation. However, he stated, it wasn’t something like counting to 5 both.
“Think about being requested to rely the variety of sheets in an enormous pack of paper, the type you get from Staples,” he stated. Errors aren’t allowed, and neither are applications like Excel. Plus, “It’s important to do it 80 instances as a result of there are 40 contests with 2 candidates every.”
Adida stated he understands why hand counting sounds simple, however when you do it, you shortly notice it is a daunting course of with dozens of steps.
And naturally you do not simply rely the person sheets, however rely a number of marks on the pages. Additional, because the story notes, there are authorized deadlines to be met by this course of, which places further strain on human volunteers, which can virtually actually enhance the error fee.
There are additionally prices concerned (hand counting is doesn’t the fiscally conservative choice):
At a gathering in Austin of greater than 500 native occasion chairmen in September, Christina Adkins, the state’s elections division director, warned that prices may shortly spiral uncontrolled.
“It is fully attainable that your prices may exceed our means to pay for the first,” she stated, standing behind a podium inside a big resort ballroom. For greater than an hour, Adkins went by way of slide after slide of a presentation detailing the principles, procedures and logistical necessities of a hand rely. “If everybody within the state goes handy counting, we would not have the funds to pay for every thing.”
[…]
Adkins instructed every occasion chair within the room contemplating a hand rely to check out how a lot a earlier related election value them and take into account the truth that further employees, additional hours and extra provides can be wanted.
She additionally did not waver on one level: No county will likely be allowed to observe the regulation due to the logistical difficulties of hand counting.
The entire notion that hand counting is a good suggestion stems from the poisoned logic that we’ve got an election fraud downside on this nation (spoiler: we do not) and particularly that the voting machines are rigged (ask Fox Information’ checking account about that one). It’s additional compounded by (once more) “frequent sense” that machines (in concept) may be manipulated, whereas good previous folks can rely!
Aspect observe: I assure that the scantron machine I used to grade a number of selection exams did a much more correct job of grading a stack of exams than if I had achieved them manually. (And that machine was a hell of rather a lot quicker!).
This entire state of affairs is a good illustration of how false narratives (just like the one which we’ve got a critical election fraud downside on this nation) result in mass misunderstanding and due to this fact to essentially silly public coverage selections being made. All of that is actually an instance of Republican activists dumbing down their supporters over time.
Please observe that this isn’t the sort of judgment I normally prefer to make, however it’s empirically true and never a normative judgement. Organizations just like the Heritage Basis have been very particularly and actively pushing the election fraud narrative for a while. I wrote about their “database” right here a while in the past with a follow-up publish that additional mentioned the “database” and demonstrated how this “data” was used at CPAC (by a author for Nationwide Overview) to boldly inform the Large Lie narrative about 2020. Past these particulars, the truth is that an amazing majority of the occasion has both straight subscribed to the Large Lie or, on the very least, been obnoxious about it. Take into account the apparent sign despatched on January 6, 2021, when 147 Republicans voted towards confirming the election.
You reap what you sow, and the GOP has been sowing mistrust in elections and democracy for fairly a while. The saying “rubbish in, rubbish out” is about programming a pc, however this can be very true about people. Supposedly apparent, simple, common sense solutions (“If you happen to go ‘1, 2, 3, 4, 5’ then you are able to do it”) oh so not often are they meant to be.
I’ll conclude by noting that the best irony of the entire idea of counting by hand as a substitute of utilizing machines is that it opens the door to a better chance of huge fraud than sticking with the machines. It is going to positively introduce extra errors within the outcomes.