![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgFu-oVqOE7h6cayv-GAcL-z91B3FZWN-8aOAtPuCIZYsU29z_AMqztaLFv1lUMN7u_SEstoM7SOpY3Ii_hdM2GOXirgmAFEW987j3X2Xzap5z3uvp6UJJQYIZgwLPGb8rSN0Pm0DOZ5ZQfGJNQr-NC_Ki_LzhpKC826XELB9nj1uo06iiUwOmCeyK9qPju/w201-h151/20240416_131109.jpg)
I’m presently in essentially the most great Helsinki airport ready to get again to Berlin. I’ve been in Helsinki to review the Finnish case for the Phil/Ora/Steve ebook on protection companies. It has been a incredible albeit chilly and principally moist week. It’s actually glad that we have now this case on the ebook, and sure, it makes it crucial to go to Sweden to see how NATO membership is a typical course of with maybe not solely frequent insurance policies.
First the enjoyment of Helsinki earlier than I talk about what I discovered for the ebook mission. It is within the Baltics, so when the wind blows, brrrrr. Sure, we bought some snow right here final evening, nicely into April. Makes me really feel like I am again in Canada, besides Ottawa has extra solar and never as a lot chilly wind. That is solely my second time right here and the primary hardly counts because it was a brief stopover between Leningrad (that tells you the way way back it was) and NY. I bought used to monitoring across the metropolis and by no means used the metro as all had been very nicely positioned within the heart apart from just a few interviews – one required a bus experience to past Helsinki and one or two required a taxi experience.
![]() |
Two parliament buildings and funky sculpture |
Considered one of my favourite new interview experiences was that they’d a convention heart the place folks may maintain conferences with far much less safety and problem than going out to the ministries. I nonetheless managed to go to the Ministry of the Inside, which was not distant, and to the Ministry of Overseas Affairs, which was a 20 minute stroll or 15 minute tram experience. The parliament buildings weren’t solely large (everybody stored reminding me that it is a small nation with a small inhabitants), however their parliament constructingp recommend in any other case), but in addition had extra safety than every other legislative constructing I can bear in mind. In fact, all have a entrance entrance with thick home windows, x-ray scanners, and so on., however to get from level a to b inside, my companion needed to really feel the doorways each 5 or ten steps. And, sure, my escort was the adviser to the protection committee, and on the best way out… a parliamentarian who was just lately chief of protection! By the best way, they do not have a lot of a historical past of senior exmil leaders serving in parliament, however Ukraine modified that. Extra on that under.
![]() |
reindeer on potato |
I am not an enormous fan of fish, so I tended to search for non-Finnish meals (not all Finnish meals is fish, to be clear), so I had Chinese language, Italian, Center Jap and Georgian. Fairly certain it was my first time getting Georgian meals, however the waitress did not perceive my order so I did not get the traditional huge flatbread, so I will need to attempt that in Berlin (I discovered a Georgian place close to my house). The folks had been very pleasant, though I’ve no Finnish. All of them perceive that nobody speaks Finnish besides the Finns, so all of them communicate Swedish (there’s a vital Swedish minority and the Swedes used to run the place), and English. Some folks seen that youngsters as of late are much less eager about studying Russian. A lot for Russia’s delicate energy….
Sure, Russia loomed massive right here, as Finns have a powerful reminiscence of the trauma of the Winter Warfare – their battle with the Russians throughout World Warfare II. Apparently, the Ukraine warfare hit the outdated ones very onerous. I questioned the place the bunkers had been as I had heard that civil protection is an enormous factor right here. Apparently I did not acknowledge the indicators once I was informed that just about all of Helsinki has underground amenities. The distinction between outdated American bomb shelters and Finnish bunkers – the latter is used day by day – parking tons, swimming swimming pools, gyms, and so on. which might be underground. This retains them contemporary, their air good and, most significantly, Finns profit from going to those locations. The financial system shouldn’t be doing nicely, and it could not have a lot to do with the truth that the Finns have just about lower off most commerce with Russia.
Do Canadians and others have an issue with the entire authorities factor? Finland has complete society, complete safety. In its historical past, it has all the time been alone till … the final yr. So they’re able to mobilize the entire group if the Russians assault. This implies a draft (for males solely [all young men including one NBA player]girls can be a part of the army, however their conscription is voluntary [holy oxymoron]), an in depth reservist system, permitting the small military to swell to 280,000 after which 900,000, coordinating all components of society to reply to an assault. The draftees are paid round 5 Euros a day…. which does not go far in tremendous costly Helsinki.
![]() |
Decorations contained in the Parl constructing |
The army has for an extended, very long time run a month-long protection course 4x/yr the place they create cohorts of fifty folks, elites from throughout society, to be taught concerning the army and the remainder of complete safety. That is one hell of an effort at public diplomacy – it ain’t low cost, though some companies present meals and booze and such totally free. Firms do not appear to have a lot of an issue with shedding an worker for a month. To offer a comparability, the military train I did in 2019 was sooner or later. This expertise is admittedly necessary because it got here up in virtually all of the interviews and principally with out my prompting.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgYiesDUaMvRakdKztoTlGS9yapyYZsz3shu52ZpR34N4F6Tt4ZS3xtk-gz1BcDRPTdqpMdgjb2Te0bBY5xsy6meQQg1lkC9OW33QzB2L3987646mOnXEKzJR4XmwYmfypj1GpexCrfNheHPTZgj2Tma0fSAD0OVGWf_8eT_IX1HtxrEt_7Y23H2kK2GAA_/w224-h168/20240415_151335.jpg)
In your outdated comparative politics, the phrase warfare is completed to the state. Though not solely true, the thought is that societies developed more and more elaborate political establishments to be able to battle and win or survive in worldwide relations. It might be the case that NATO membership has the identical however smaller impact. That becoming a member of NATO has induced Finland to dramatically develop and maybe strengthen its very small protection ministry. NATO requires conferences, doc management, preparation, deployment of personnel to NATO headquarters in Brussels, Mons and elsewhere. AND most NATO insurance policies are made by civilians, though NATO is much extra a company about army issues than civilian issues (therefore a lot of the hassle to construct an Afghan authorities was pushed by separate nationwide governments (international affairs, growth companies) somewhat than of The relevance of that is that it provides the MoD a higher function in making protection coverage than earlier EU nations I’ve been to the place NATO flags simply outnumber EU flags.
Concerning the mission, Finland is an fascinating case with a largely autonomous army, that their quantity two within the Ministry of Protection is all the time a retired senior army officer, their Minister of Protection is small (150 now, swelling just lately because of NATO), their President is Commander-in-Chief, which means the army can attempt to equate the MoD and the PM by insisting that the president oversees them, the president and PM have small international/safety workplaces, and conscription deeply shapes every part. Sweden might be a humorous case to match because the Swedes had a draft, dropped it and have just lately restarted it whereas additionally just lately becoming a member of NATO.
![](https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEgVWGhzX4lXV4jcJOvk7foE0Z1MF49gYKdnQETdDkn8NVRFHIBEAwfS1Ps9c03oIRaYYGkfR6jGLABRuIn4V4WcBNH6drEgIuJW4p-uYoi-SV2PY1Cylwl2DUs10Y6oRRxEQg0CVMrHj5SbA-oFcMmPUzEK6eXgxZPd6cr08SC7c7Ht_QS0NGLu2YCLnFCi/s320/20240415_133215.jpg)
Random issues I heard alongside the best way:
- 5 totally different Baltic pipelines have had “accidents” for the reason that warfare in Ukraine began!
- Finland has reached 2% of GDP in protection as a result of it front-loaded the price of shopping for the F35, which signifies that when it goes via the system, Finland might wrestle to lift sufficient to remain at 2%.
- Uterine stools! A number of ready rooms in authorities buildings jogged my memory of Oberlin’s library approach again within the day.
I like my job, even when it requires me to transcribe my interview notes. I’ve many extra nations to go to and I nonetheless must do one thing to determine the German case in addition to write up the Finnish case. All I do know is that comparative civil-mil relations have been superb to me.
Subsequent week Mrs Spew is hitting Europe so we’re driving via Germany after which flying to Italy. So a really totally different a part of discipline work forward. Rather more targeted on comparative delicacies.